Fan Favorites: Best Pizza in Lake County

Fan Favorites

If there is one food Chicago-area people take seriously it is pizza. Everyone has an opinion on who has the best and why. In celebration of National Pizza Day (it was yesterday), we polled our Facebook Fans and present to you this comprehensive (and totally subjective) list of the Best Pizza in Lake County, IL.

best pizza in lake county

Best Pizza in Lake County

  • Slyce
    127 Main St., Wauconda 60084 | (847) 469-8840
    254 Green Bay Rd., Highwood 60040 | (847) 780-4065
  • Bill’s Pizza & Pub*
    18945 W. Washington St., Grayslake 60030 | (847) 548-9900
    624 S. Lake St., Mundelein 60060 | (847) 566-5380

Best thin crust! ~ Jen

*As part of a long-standing tradition, peanuts are served and diners are invited to shell them on the floor

I love their deep dish! ~Cindy

It’s been around forever and owned by the same family. It’s the best! ~Becky

  • Kaiser’s
    1801 North IL Route 21, Gurnee 60031 | (847) 336-6500
  • Olando’s
    843 W. Rollins, Round Lake Beach 60073 | (847) 546-2378
  • Wayne’s Pizza
    34197 Route 45, Third Lake 60030 | (847) 223-2441
  • Double D Pizza
    1500 N. Lewis Ave, Waukegan 60085 | (847) 623-4330

Don’t judge a book by its cover, this place has crazy good Double Deckers! – Kristen

  • RJ’s Eatery
    1913 E. Grand Ave., Lindenhurst 60046 | (847) 356-2300
  • Nancy’s Pizza (multiple locations)
    527 Auburn, Island Lake 60042 | (847) 487-4100

Nancy’s Pizza, Island Lake has the best chicken alfredo on rustic crust pizza! ~ Cindy

We will sometimes drive the half hour/40 minutes for it. So reasonable in price too! ~ Stephanie

Been to most of the above and this is still our fave! ~ Carly

  • Lino’s
    265 Peterson Road, Libertyville 60048 | (847) 680-0600
  • Emil’s
    161 Center St., Grayslake 60030 | (847) 543-8879

Of course, being Chicago we know that Lou Malnati’s (if you’re right) and Giordano’s’s (if you’re wrong) are on the top of everyone’s list, we just wanted to give you homegrown alternatives.

Did we get your favorite? Let us know in the comments!

About Melissa Haak 626 Articles
Melissa is mom to 4. She used to dream of traveling the world, now she dreams of a clean kitchen. She can be found on most social media sites as @PBinmyHair because with this much hair and four kids, you're bound to find something in it.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.